Peer Review Process

At the Journal of Surgery and Medicine (JOSAM), we are committed to upholding the highest standards of scientific rigor and publication ethics. JOSAM enforces a strict double-blind peer review system for all research articles, reviews, and case reports. In this process, the identities of both the authors and the reviewers are completely concealed from each other throughout the evaluation workflow, ensuring objective, unbiased, and transparent assessment.

Detailed Peer Review Workflow

  1. Initial Editorial & Technical Screening (Desk Review):
    Upon submission, the editorial secretariat and technical editors conduct an initial screening:
    • Plagiarism & Originality Screening: Every manuscript is automatically tested using professional similarity software (iThenticate / Turnitin). Submissions exceeding a 15% similarity threshold (excluding references) are immediately returned or rejected.
    • Technical Compliance: Verification of the two-file submission system (an anonymized Main Text and a separate Title Page containing all mandatory declarations, ethics approvals, and the Use of AI Statement).
    • Scope & Formatting: Alignment with JOSAM’s aims, scope, and American English language standards.
    Turnaround: Manuscripts failing this stage are returned or desk-rejected within 5–7 days.
  2. Section / Field Editor Evaluation:
    Manuscripts that pass technical screening are assigned to an Associate or Field Editor specializing in the relevant surgical or medical discipline. The Field Editor assesses scientific methodology, clinical significance, originality, and adherence to international reporting guidelines (e.g., STROBE, PRISMA, CARE). Suitable manuscripts are forwarded to external review; unsuitable submissions are rejected with constructive feedback within 1–2 weeks.
  3. External Double-Blind Peer Review:
    Manuscripts are assigned to at least two independent, external peer reviewers who are recognized experts with proven publication track records in the subject area. Reviewers evaluate:
    • Methodological validity, experimental design, and statistical accuracy.
    • Originality, clinical relevance, and novelty of the research questions.
    • Clarity of data presentation and justified conclusions.
    • Compliance with ethical standards (Declaration of Helsinki, IRB approval, informed consent).
    Reviewer Code of Conduct:
    • Treat all manuscript files and data as strictly confidential.
    • Immediately declare any potential personal, financial, or institutional conflicts of interest and decline the assignment if biased.
    • Submit objective, constructive critiques within the agreed deadline (typically 2–3 weeks).
    • Refrain from using generative AI tools to evaluate or synthesize reviews, preserving manuscript confidentiality.
  4. Discrepancy Resolution & Third Reviewer:
    In cases where opposing recommendations are issued by the two primary reviewers (e.g., one accept/minor revision and one reject), the manuscript is automatically forwarded to a third independent external reviewer or adjudicated by a Senior Section Editor to reach a balanced, merit-based decision.
  5. Editorial Decision & Revision Rounds:
    The Editor-in-Chief synthesizes reviewer recommendations and issues one of the following decisions:
    • Accept: The manuscript meets all standards and moves to in-house copyediting and typesetting.
    • Minor Revision: Authors are requested to address editorial or clarifying comments within 14 days.
    • Major Revision: Extensive revisions or additional data re-analyses are required within 30 days. Revised manuscripts are re-evaluated by the original reviewers. Authors must provide an itemized, point-by-point response letter detailing all modifications.
    • Reject: The manuscript lacks sufficient novelty, rigor, or ethical compliance.

Ethical Governance & COPE Alignment

JOSAM strictly adheres to the core practices defined by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the ICMJE Recommendations, and the World Association of Medical Editors (WAME). Editors, reviewers, and authors are expected to act in full accordance with international academic integrity frameworks.

Handling Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions

To safeguard the integrity of the permanent scholarly record:

  • Corrections (Errata / Corrigenda): Minor factual or typographic errors that do not compromise the scientific conclusions will be published as linked correction notices.
  • Expressions of Concern: Published if conclusive evidence of research misconduct has not yet been established during ongoing investigations.
  • Retractions: Executed strictly according to the COPE Retraction Guidelines in cases of proven data fabrication, unethical research, redundant publication, or pervasive plagiarism.

JOSAM Peer Review Workflow Diagram

JOSAM Double-Blind Peer Review Workflow